Prime Burger Bar Menu – Commack, NY

Type : Restaurant

Location : Commack, NY

Using only the freshest of ingredients the menu at Prime Burger offers a delicious array of salads, appetizers, hand cut fries, Super Duper milkshakes and, of course, Our World Famous Burgers!

Our burgers are a proprietary blend of PRIME Chuck, Short Rib & Ribeye Steak.
USDA Prime is the highest quality level available for all graded American raised beef. USDA Prime only accounts for around 3% of all beef sold in the United States. Prime Burger Bar sells this type of beef exclusively.

Finished with our incomparable preparation and presentation…our continued goal is to exceed the expectations of every hungry appetite and any “burger enthusiast” equally!

Based on 284 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.3 stars. Price $$

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery

Prime Burger Bar 11725

6092 Jericho Turnpike, Commack, NY 11725

Phone: (631) 486-9414


Social Profile:


Tuesday 4–9 PM
Wednesday 12–9 PM
Thursday 12–9 PM
Friday 12–10 PM
Saturday 12–10 PM
Sunday 12–9 PM
Monday 4–9 PM


Chef’s Sandwiches
Ribeye Steak Sammie
Ribeye steak grilled to temp, sliced and served on a garlic buttered grilled rustic hero, charred red onions melted fontina cheese and horseradish sauce.
Farmhouse Chicken Sandwich
Buttermilk fried chicken, lettuce, tomato, pickle, topped with our house sauce.
Ultimate Grilled Cheese
Grilled sourdough with tomato jam, braised short rib. Onion straws, fontina and cheddar cheese.
Prime Burger Grilled Cheese
Grilled sourdough with cheddar, Swiss and American cheese with tomatoes.
Avocado Grilled Cheese
Grilled sourdough with cheddar, fontina, pepper jack and Swiss with avocado.
Crispy lettuce, sliced beefsteak tomato plied high with cuspy applewood smoked bacon and a maple aioli.
Grilled Chicken BLTA
House marinated grilled all natural chicken breast with avocado spread, crispy lettuce, sliced beefsteak tomato. Applewood smoked bacon, griddled sourdough.
Grandma’s Chicken Sandwich
Breaded chicken cutlets served on a toasted rustic hero, topped with roasted red pepper, fresh mozzarella and balsamic glaze.
Baja Chicken
Blackened all natural chicken breast, red onions, avocado spread, bacon mayo, melted pepper jack cheese served on a pretzel roll.
Buffalo Chicken Sandwich
Buttermilk fried chicken, pepper jack cheese, buffalo sauce, and bleu cheese. Served on a pretzel bun.
Classic Wings
Choose from mild, medium or hot, honey BBQ or sweet teriyaki. Served with carrots, celery and bleu cheese.
Reverse Wings
Crispy fried and tossed in blue cheese served with carrots and celery. Choice of wing sauce served on side.
Thai inspired peanut butter and jelly wing sauce.
Boneless Wings
Breaded and fried chicken strips tossed in your choice of mild, medium, hot sauce, sweet teriyaki sauce or honey BBQ served with carrots, celery and blue cheese.
Giant Bavarian Pretzel
Ale mustard, honey mustard, house cheese sauce.
Spinach Artichoke Dip
PBB’s take on this classic dish made with five types of cheese served with tortilla chips.
Fried Sprouts
Crispy brussel sprouts, maple bacon glaze.
Avocado Toast
Avocado spread, olives, roasted peppers, burrata, grilled sourdough bread.
Short Rib Sliders
Braised short rib, onion straws, tomato-onion jam with a cabernet sauce.
Onion Rings
Fried battered onion.
Cheeseburger Sliders
Mini versions of our proprietary burger blend, American cheese, pickle chips.
The Everything Pretzel $13.95
New England Clam Chowder
House made with fresh local clams and potatoes in a creamy clam broth.
Cobb Salad
Grilled chicken breast, bacon, hard boiled egg, tomato, bleu cheese crumbles, avocado, romaine, iceberg lettuce.
Kale Salad
Baby kale with pepitas, dried cranberries, roasted brussel sprouts, bacon and crumbled goat cheese with a spiced pumpkin vinaigrette.
Tex Mex Salad
A veggie power blend of golden beets, broccoli, kohlrabi, brussel sprouts, radicchio and carrots. Mixed with corn salsa, avocado, Cajun almonds, cotija cheese and tortilla strips in a poblano avocado dressing.
House Salad
Moved greens, cucumbers, tomato, red onion, shaved carrot. Honey balsamic dressing.
Wedge Salad
Iceburg lettuce, bacon, tomato, crumbled blue cheese and crispy onions with blue cheese dressing.
Greek Salad
Crisp romaine, shaved red onion, kalamata black olives, cucumber, tomato, feta cheese and Greek dressing.
Avocado Caesar Salad
romaine lettuce, avocado, croutons & parmesan cheese served with caesar dressing. Add grilled Chicken for an additional price.
Crispy house cut fries topped with white cheddar cheese curds and brown gravy.
Short Rib
Crispy house cut fries topped with cabernet braised pulled short rib. White cheddar cheese curds and brown gravy.
Mac & Cheese
Creamy Bacon Mac & Cheese
Cavatappi pasta, loaded with cheese and bacon topped with a butter cracker crust.
Short Rib Mac & Cheese
Cavatappi pasta, loaded with cheese and cabernet braised pulled short rib.
Buffalo Mac & Cheese
Cavatappi pasta, loaded with cheese and mixed with panko breaded chicken, choice of mild, medium or hot buffalo sauce.
Chef’s Burgers
Greek Lamb Burger
Seasoned with Mediterranean herbs and spices, lettuce, tomato, onion, tzatziki sauce.
Burrata Burger
8oz of our proprietary blend topped with roasted red peppers, tomato-onion jam, and creamy burrata cheese with balsamic drizzle.
Bacon On Bacon
8oz of our proprietary blend infused with bacon, topped with bacon jam, applewood smoked bacon and American cheese.
Drunken Goat
8oz of our proprietary blend, herb honey whipped goat cheese, candied bacon and cabernet sauce.
Tex Mex Burger
8oz of our proprietary blend, charred red onion, avocado spread, chipotle aioli and crumbled cotia cheese.
Black N Blue
8oz of our proprietary blend seasoned and blackened, topped with applewood smoked bacon and blue cheese.
Fire Island
8oz of our proprietary blend with pepper jack cheese, bacon, fresh jalapeno and chipotle aioli.
Great South Bay
8oz of our proprietary blend topped with braised short rib, caramelized onions, swiss cheese and cabernet sauce.
Breakfast Burger
8oz of our proprietary blend copped with bacon jam, a fried egg and maple aioli.
BBQ Burger
8oz of our proprietary blend copped with applewood smoked bacon, BBQ sauce. Onion straws and pickles.
North Shore Kobe
8oz Kobe beef topped with swiss cheese, caramelized mushrooms and cabernet sauce.
Ahi Tuna
6oz fresh cut ahi tuna seared rare with a ponzu glaze, topped with a red bell pepper and cabbage slaw with house ginger dressing.
The Beyond Burger
100% vegan burger with 20g plant based protein, no gmos, no soy or gluten, topped with citrus dressed mixed greens and sliced cucumber on a multi grain bun.
Turkey Burger
House seasoned ground turkey, topped with melted mozzarella, tomato-onion jam and citrus dressed mixed greens on a multigrain bun.
Build Your Own Burger Experience
Build Your Own Burger Experience
Fresh tomatoes, red onion, lettuce and dill pickle upon request served with house cut fries or house made coleslaw.
The Juicy Lucy
The Juicy Lucy
8oz of our proprietary blend stuffed with American cheese topped with caramelized onion, tomato, pickled cucumber and house sauce on a challah bun.
The Steak House
The Steak House
8oz prime aged beef blend served on a challah bun with cheddar cheese, onion ring, lettuce, tomato and bb steak sauce.
The Mac & Cheese
The Mac & Cheeseburger
8oz of our proprietary blend topped with mac and cheese, cheese sauce and bacon on a challah bun.
House Cut $6.95
Truffle $9.95
Loaded Fries
House cut fries topped with cheese sauce, bacon, scallions.
Sweet Potato Waffle Fries
With marshmallow dipping sauce.
Vanilla $8.00
Chocolate $8.00
Black & White $8.00
Fresh Strawberry $8.00
Oreo Cookies N’ Cream
handspun oreo cookies n’ cream milkshake, vanilla frosting & oreo cookies on the nm, topped off with an oreo cookies n’ cream ice cream sandwich, whipped cream, crushed oreo cookies, drizzled with hershey’s chocolate syrup.
Kid’s Menu
Grilled Cheese
Traditional grilled cheese sammie served with house cut fries.
Mac N’ Cheese
Cavatappi pasta with house made cheese sauce blend.
Chicken Fingers
Fried chicken strips served with house cut fries.
Hot Dog
All natural beef hot dog served with house cut fries.
Burger Slider
4oz hamburger slider served with house cut fries.
Summer Menu
Lobster Bisque
Our lobster bisque is slow cooked for great lobster flavor.
Lobster Cobb Salad
Traditional lobster salad, bacon, hard-boiled egg, tomato, cucumber, and feta cheese, served over romaine lettuce and your choice of dressing.
Traditional New England Lobster Roll
Traditional cold lobster salad, toasted potato roll, coleslaw, and homemade potato chips.
Warm Lobster Roll
Warm buttered lobster, toasted potato roll, coleslaw, and homemade potato chips.
Lobster Mac & Cheese
Cavatappi pasta, loaded with cheese and fresh lobster, topped with breadcrumbs.
Lobster Grilled Cheese
Warm buttered lobster and cheddar cheese served on buttery pressed sourdough bread. Served with homemade potato chips.

… View more

Photo Gallery


Howie Alli
The place in a strip mall with ample parking. You can’t go wrong with their burgers which they are noted for. I had the bacon on bacon which I enjoyed and recommend. The fries were not good. Limp, soggy and greesy. Cole slaw was very good. We had a table of 6 and service was superb from waiter Joe and food was cooked to perfection. I will be coming back.

… more

Ben Cox
When it comes to burgers this spot knows the way, not only was it perfectly cooked but the flavor was top tier. I was hesitant to get the wings but after one bite they are a must have. Staff went above and beyond my whole stay, will definitely be coming back! Had the pleasure of meeting Tatum, she blessed our group with great hospitality!

… more

Dana D’Amico
The burgers were delicious.. the fries were great. The shakes were good also

… more

David Rubin
Food was pretty good but not stellar – and not for what it cost. Got the fire island burger – no spice to it at all. Kids got shakes that were crazy big and they seemed to enjoy. Wings were good. Fries we ok. Probably would go back but would try something else.

… more

Diane Tierney
My food was ok but my niece’s fiance wasn’t happy with his meal. He said the bacon on his sandwich was too hard he couldn’t bite into it. He got the wrong fries. He wanted sweet potato fries and got regular. His beer was poured wrong. No head foam on his Guinness beer. Our server was nice but a little slow.

… more

Steven Gildin
Interesting place. Think of Applebee’s or a Long Island Diner, but much better.

… more

Sarah Rosenberg
service was good. nice waitress. food was terrible… had spinach & artichoke dip which barely had any spinach in it and tasted like nothing.. stale chips. burger meat was good but the bun was soooo stale as well as the fries. not good food

… more

Sam Fenner
Wow wow wow!!! We just picked up two burgers from Prime Burger Bar in Commack and it was an absolutely FANTASTIC dinner!

… more

Mike Grimaldi
I got the Great South Bay which is 8oz of our proprietary blend topped with braised short rib, caramelized onions, Swiss cheese and cabernet sauce. Price for this bad boy is $18.95. Burger was delicious and generous with the toppings. The short rib that was on it, was really good! I would def get this burger again. It was a touch over cooked for what I ordered but the burger was so good I don’t have any complaints! Price is steep but you get what you pay for! This is the real deal! Give it a try! Make sure you are hungry!!!!

… more

Anthony p
Great local Commack eatery!

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions