Prohibition Port Jefferson Menu – Port Jefferson, NY

Type : American restaurant

Location : Port Jefferson, NY

Now OPEN Tuesdays 4-9 for Taco Tuesday Menu Takeover!
We serve Illegally good food! Offering HAPPY HOUR Mondays, Wednesdays, Thursdays and Fridays 5-7pm at the bar. 1/2 price apps, beer, wine and bottles of wine. Reservations now available for parties of 9 or more

Based on 382 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.5 stars. Price

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery

Prohibition Port Jefferson 11777

Address:
115 Main St, Port Jefferson, NY 11777

Phone: (631) 473-0613

Website: http://www.prohibitionpj.com/

Social Profile:

Hours

Tuesday 4:30–9 PM
Wednesday 4:30–9 PM
Thursday 4:30–9 PM
Friday 12 PM–12 AM
Saturday 11 AM–10 PM
Sunday 11 AM–7 PM
Monday 4:30–9 PM

Menu

The D Word
Super Duper S’mores
our warm fudge brownie topped with vanilla gelato, hot fudge, torched marshmallow cream and a sprinkle of buttery graham crackers. Finished with a drizzle of fudge sauce
Ultra Mega Peanut Butter Cup Spectacular
our brown butter blondie with peanut butter cups, vanilla or chocolate ice cream, crushed peanut butter cups and a double drizzle of peanut butter sauce and hot fudge
Apple Crisp Explosion
cinnamon spiced gala apples topped with dirty crumb, Maldon sea salt, vanilla gelato, finished with a drizzle of caramel sauce
Blue Ribbon Skillet
Thick chocolate chip cookie served warm with a chocolate ganache center topped with vanilla or chocolate gelato and a drizzle of fudge sauce
Mike’s Hot Honey Chip Ala Mode
house made, hand cut yukon gold potato chips, mikes hot honey, vanilla ice cream, cinnamon drizzle topped with a little extra honey sauce…think of cornflakes in ice cream, a totally unique experience
Maple Flap Jack Cake
blueberry layer cake with fresh maple cream layers, topped with whipped cream and blueberry compote…just like a breakfast!
East Main & Main Donut Bread Pudding
At the end of the day, your favorite donuts become our amazing donut bread pudding! Topped with sprinkles and a drizzle of vanilla frosting, this is so worthy of the calories!
Dirty Elvis
Peanut butter, banana, a slice of our cold smoked bacon…and some great dance moves
The Captains Cinnamon Toast Crunch
Cinnamon ice cream, crushed captain crunch, salted caramel drizzle topped with cinnamon toast crunch crumbles and salted caramel crisp pearls
Johnny Appleseed
the wanderer-Vanilla ice cream, gala apple, salted caramel crispy pearls, whipped cream and a caramel stroopwaffle
Contraband Cocktails
Smokey Williamsburg
Pelaton de Muerte Mezcal, Fresh Lime, Ginger Simple Syrup, Greenport Juicy IPA		 $12.00
Second Breakfast
Rough Rider Bourbon, Fresh Lemon, Crown Smoked Maple Syrup, Ginger Beer, Fresh Blueberry		 $12.00
Justin’s Deadly Daiquiri
Bly Silver Rum, Simple Syrup, Fresh Lime Juice		 $12.00
New Old Fashioned
Hillrock Rye, Simple Syrup, Ango, Raft Orange Bitters		 $12.00
Backyard Martini
Deepwells Gin, Backyard Brine Brine, Dill Death Do us Part Dill Pickle		 $12.00
Paloma
Pueblo Viejo Tequilla, Fresh Grapefruit, Mikes Hot Honey		 $12.00
Dark Side Absinthe Cocktail
Liepold Brothers Absinthe, Demerara Sugar Cube, Saratoga Water		 $12.00
Ferments From The East
Representing the best Wine of Long Island
Bridge Lane White Merlot
Bridge Lane Steel Chardonnay
Classic Carriers
Oak Fermented Chardonnay
Toasty, Oaky, Tasty		 $12.00
Sauvignon Blanc
Crisp, Light, Bright		 $10.00
Cabernet Franc
Dark Cherry, Black Pepper, Tom’s Fav		 $12.00
Cabernet Sauvignon
Fruit Forward, Long Finish, Big Plums		 $12.00
Early Wine
Super tasty, Light and Sweet, Fresh Fruit		 $12.00
Dos Aguas White Blend
Bright, Clean, Light Acidity		 $12.00
Dos Aguas Red Blend
Mellow Finish, Light fruit, Coffee, Jamesport Vineyards
Dry Reisling
Crisp, Vibrant, Clean		 $11.00
Syrah
Smoked, Cherry, Anise		 $14.00
Pythagoris Blend
Mineral Start, Jammy Blackberry, Light Tannin		 $11.00
Summer In A Bottle
Hamptons Gatorade, Clean, Super Drinkablity		 $16.00
Finca Rose
Bright Peach, Raspberry, Strawberry		 $12.00
Main Menu
Avocado Toast
Big Boy Cut Sourdough, Avocado Crema, Poached Egg, Backyard Brine Bloody Seasoning		 $13.00
Chicken And Waffle
Coleman Organic/Antibiotic Free Chicken Breast, Quinoa and Kale Waffle, Bourbon Barrel Aged Maple Syrup		 $15.00
Superman Steel Cut Oats
Verjus Poached Pear, Grape, Dried Grape, Granola, Honey		 $11.00
Corned Beef Jack Benny
Thick Chop corned beef Hash, Poach Egg, Hollandaise, British Muffin		 $13.00
On A Hot Tin Roof
Ham and Cheese Stuffed biscuits smothered in Chorizo white gravy		 $14.00
Prohibition Skillet
Quinoa, Potato Kale Hash. White cheddar Sauce, Poached Egg		 $13.00
Southern Scramble
Jumbo Shrimp, Smoked Cheddar Chorizo Gravy, Crispy Grit, Scramble		 $19.00
Big Daddy
Cinnamon Chipotle Braised Pork Shoulder, Onion Tanglers, Egg, Poblano Chile sauce Roasted Sprouts		 $16.00
Sloppy Scramble
Green Chile Aioli, Burnt Ends, Peppered Bacon, Super Sloppy Eggs		 $15.00
Hot Buttered Russ
Lemon Poppy Pound Cake, French Toast Batter, Lemon Blueberry Compote		 $14.00
Hot Tub Time Machine
Big HOT Waffle, Vanilla Maple Glaze, Pearl Sugar		 $16.00
O’Canada
Porter Infused Gravy, Short Rib, Poutine Queso, Garlic Donut Holes		 $13.00
Twilight Zone
Creamy Cheese Sauce, Shells, Cracker Crumb, Bacon, Franks Red Hot		 $11.00
‘Mozz Squad
Burrata Mozzarella, Fire Roasted Tomato, Hemp Pesto, Roasted Garlic Donut		 $14.00
Big Boy Giant Pretzel
Hatch Chile infused Beer Queso, Grain Mustard		 $12.00
Daddy-O
Thick Cut House Cut onion Rings, Ginger Habanero Chile Sauce		 $10.00
Big Wedge
Artisan Romaine Lettuce, Roasted Heirloom Tomato, Chunky Blue Cheese Dressing, Bacon, Everything Bagel Seasoning		 $15.00
Snazzy Sprouts
Braised Brussel Sprouts, Bourbon Barrel Aged Maple Syrup, Wildflower Honey, Local Sea Salt		 $12.00
Chip And Dip
Yukon Gold Potato Chips, Smoked Pork and Gorgonzola Dip, Green Onion, Cracker Crumb		 $13.00
Pbj Wings
Roasted Organic Chicken Wing, Crushed Peanut Satay, Thai Chili Jelly		 $14.00
Frito Pie
Certified Angus Beef Chili, Queso Fresco, Chile Lime Crema, Cold Cheese, Fritos		 $12.00
Thinking About Gym
Sweet Potato Hummus, Crispy Sprouts, EVOO, Ras El Hanout		 $14.00
Flat Foot Falaffel
Baby Kale, Beets, Hemp Seed, Avocado, Toasted Chick Pea, Watermelon Radish, English Cucumber, Quinoa Salad, Crispy Pita		 $18.00
Prohibition Poutine
Wedge Monster Fries, Poutine Gravy		 $12.00
The G.O.A.T
Fried Green Tomato, Local Goat Cheese, BYB Sriracha Slaw, Micro Daikon		 $15.00
Prohibition Provisions And Baby Cheeses
A smattering of our favorite local Charcuterie, Cheese, Jam, and Stuff		 $24.00
Locavore
East end Tomato, Local Goat Cheese, Wildflower Honey, Local Sea Salt, Non Local Olive Oil		 $16.00
Edamame Dumplings
Blood Orange Braised King Oyster Mushrooms		 $13.00
Dirty Mother Clucker
Southern Fried Chicken, Sweet Glazed Donut		 $14.00
The G Man
Cinnamon/Chipotle Pork shoulder, Onion Tanglers, Lime Crema, Prohibition Slaw		 $15.00
What’s Your Beef?
Certified Angus Beef Smash Burger, Roasted Serrano Chile Queso, LTOP, Swell Sauce		 $15.00
Hotsie Totsie
Coleman Organic/Antibiotic Free Chicken, I put that S*it on everything Sauce, Fromage Blue Cheese Dressing		 $16.00
8 Slice Death Punch
Big Boy Cut Sourdough, Grueyre, American, Burrata, Tomato, Bacon		 $14.00
Kobayashi Dog
Duo of Certified Angus Beef Hot Dogs, Backyard Brine Sriracha Slaw, Kewpie Mayo, Nori, Other Green Stuff		 $13.00
Puttin On The Ritz
Crispy #1 Sushi Grade Tuna, Mango, Avo, Pickled Shishito Pepper, Firecracker Mizuna, Chipotle Mango Crema		 $19.00
The Fruit Of The Sea
Pan Seared Right coast Shrimp, Avocado, Hemp seed, LI Tomato, Crispy Grit, RRP		 $16.00
Captain Midnight
Certified Angus Beef Smash Burger, All American Cheese, All American Bacon, All American Coleslaw, Super Swell Sauce		 $17.00

… View more

Menu Photos

Photo Gallery

Reviews

Oded Haker
This is a super nice spot. The only reason I didn’t give 5 stars all over the board, is because I’m a condescending dude from Manhattan…

… more

Christmas Dude
Prohibition Port Jeff’s instagram has been making my mouth water for years on instagram and it’s taken me way too long to finally get there and after making it there yesterday for the first time, it was more than worth the wait! Everything was perfect in my experience. Our hostess was both informative extremely inviting, and attentive as she took the best care of me and my wife as we waited for a table to open up on a busy and beautiful day in Port Jeff. We ended up ordering the special monthly cocktail on her recommendation as we hung out by the bar, where all of the patrons were welcoming, and we relished in how good the recommended Bloody Mary was! The atmosphere was so chill, warm, and cozy. After being seated our waitress was as diligent as they come. Taking our order promptly and making sure our water was always filled. The food was out of this world delicious! I partook in a boozy brunch with my wife where I had the Belgian waffle and it was honestly one of the best breakfasts I’ve had on Long Island. My partner got a Benny bowl that she couldn’t help but share just to have me join in on tasting how exquisite the roasted veggies and potatoes were. The whole experience was memorable and I honestly cannot wait to come back here throughout the summer!

… more

Gregory Barbera
Charming place in the village of Port Jefferson. We each had burgers, and it was full of flavor. Nice atmosphere. Great staff and nice menu. Check it out.

… more

Michele McHugh
Food and service were great. Ambience is adorable. Only concern was that it was cold inside. Even the wait staff was cold. Of course, it was single digits outside. Would be great if a little warmer!

… more

Mike L
Enjoyed a late lunch/early dinner here. Veronica waited on us – she was amazing. Genuinely welcoming and friendly – it is people like her that made our experience here memorable.

… more

Eric San José
Easy to see right off of East Main Street servicing Port Jefferson and the adjoining areas of Suffolk County. A nice looking interior with retro speakeasy feel. Clean facilities. Public Restroom. Staff is nice. Went here for brunch on a Sunday. My Eggs Benedict (poached) were a little over cooked. Shoe string fries were good. Nice bar with weekly food and drink specials. Reasonably priced. Credit cards accepted. Nice staff.

… more

Tom De
Very cool little spot in the heart of the village. Creative craft cocktails and a solid, varied beer list. Was really impressed by the half off happy hour menu on some drinks and small plates. Wouldn’t expect that with the items on the small plates menu, ended up making a meal out of those. Will be visiting again for some large plates!

… more

Sal Verdi
I’ve had my eye on this place for a long time. I’m soooo glad I finally ate here . I went for

… more

ButteryRolls
My girlfriend and I decided to go to Prohibition Kitchen for our 1 year anniversary, and we were absolutely blown away in every aspect.

… more

robert pompano
I came here with friends that live in the area with high expectations, but was disappointed in the end. I did like the eccentric vibe of the establishment itself.

… more

… View more

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch