Intimate destination for upscale Italian cooking in a Tuscan-villa setting with murals & an atrium. Based on 294 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ Delivery
Address:
175 E Main St, Babylon, NY 11702
Phone: (631) 321-6392
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 4–9 PM |
| Wednesday | 4–9 PM |
| Thursday | 4–9 PM |
| Friday | 4–10 PM |
| Saturday | 4–10 PM |
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
| Monday | Closed |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Order and Reservations
Reservations: exploretock.com
Reviews
In Wonder
Homemade pasta was delicious and I reccomend the canoli martini and the icecream sandwich was huge and an amazing dessert the staff was on point and the ambiance was amazing. It’s not far from their storefront in babylon. They also have their own parking lot. Becareful when you put in the navigation not to use the address for the store down the road.
… more
Elmira Michilovich
The first time here, and extremely impressed with everything! Great service,super fast, the food was super delicious . One of the best Italian restaurants! Pasta is something else! Highly recommend!!!!
… more
Nicole Taveras
We came here on 7/1 for my wedding anniversary. We have been here before and liked it a lot, but this last visit helped me to decided to never return. The food was good. Our server was horrendous. I don’t know her name because every time she came over I cringed. She has short spiky hair and blue eyes. Every single time she came over she wanted to DISTASTEFULLY joke with my husband. It was beyond overboard to the point that she was really annoying. She joked about what happens after my husband eats his lobster…in the toilet. Train your servers better Gemellis.
… more
Katie Lyver
I have always wanted to try this restaurant as it always looks so cute from the outside and I’ve heard great things. I’m not sure what the problem was but there were very few families inside and the wait was forever. The waitress insisted on reading us the specials when we already knew what we wanted…. we sat without drinks and bread/olives for an extended period of time but we were patient and not really in a rush.
… more
Robin Magliato
I ate at this restaurant , 2 weeks ago. Ugh! Awful. I will never go back. My first impression was the watery ,almost clear olive oil placed on the table, with the bread, for dipping. It was clear, no flavor, almost like water. I asked for a different oil. 15 minutes later this waiter brought me a container of an olive oil , that at least had some green color and some flavor. My Cavatelli , in a tomatoe cream sauce , was piled in a small bowl, with a few unmelted mozzarella pieces on top.This bowl was sitting on a white plate. No platting whatsoever
… more
Paulette Cacoperdo
I can’t believe I have never been here and live so close. Everything from the service to the drinks to the food was outstanding and I cannot wait to go back. Our waiter was on top of everything constantly checking on us. Making great suggestions and he was funny. We did not feel rushed and the time between courses was perfect. My Cosmo was so good. For apps we had baked clams and Arancini perfecto. We shared a Caesar salad, the presentation of the salad was beautiful and tasted even better. For dinner I had the linguine and clams which was one of the best I have ever had and hubby had the seafood linguini which he said was amazing. I love that the portions are not huge so you don’t feel like you’re wasting food. We were too full for dessert but will definitely try the next time. If you have never been you are missing out.
… more
Manoj Modi
Wasn’t sure where I wanted to eat but I am glad that we ended up coming here. The food drink and service was excellent. Would definitely recommend to anyone who is looking for Italian food.
… more
Natalia Hanson
5 stars for the Old World interior decorations, art pieces and Italian memorabilia, amazing service and friendly waiters, 4 starts would be more appropriate for food. Cozy place for a date night dinner.
… more
Tai Vicari
I am truly impressed with the service and the cuisine. Gemelli is just wonderful.
… more
Stacey Ruffin
If I was just rating the food, it would be hands down FIVE STARS. However, although we made reservations and the hostesses were very friendly and nice, please don’t go there very hungry. They are clearly understaffed. We had a male waiter, and another waitress was in our area as well tending to other tables. Our first round of drinks arrived within five minutes. However, the appetizers and the main course we had to wait so long that we thought we were forgotten. For the two of us, our bill was well over $200 plus a credit card charge of $10. Please be mindful of the credit card charge. All that said, our dinner was delicious!
… more
… View more