Sad Pie Pizza Menu – Columbus, OH

Type : Pizza restaurant

Location : Columbus, OH

Based on 17 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $

✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery

Sad Pie Pizza 43201

Address:
1282 Essex Ave, Columbus, OH 43201

Phone:

Website:

Hours

Wednesday 5:30 PM–12 AM
Thursday 5:30 PM–1 AM
Friday 5:30 PM–2 AM
Saturday 5:30 PM–2 AM
Sunday 5:30 PM–12 AM
Monday Closed
Tuesday 5:30 PM–12 AM

Menu

Sad Pies
Check Yes, Cheesiest
Three, two, one, pizza in my arms now. Our 12” garlic butter crust topped with red sauce and mozzarella cheese		 $12.34
This Ain’t A Cheese It’s A Pep-Per-O-Ni
Our 12” garlic butter crust topped with red sauce, mozzarella cheese, and pepperoni. Jiminy jillikers		 $12.34
Where Are You? & I’m So Sausage
Our 12” crust topped with red sauce, mozzarella cheese, and sausage		 $12.34
Build Your Own Pizza
Build Your Own Pizza
Pizza! at tonight’s dinner. Build your own 12″ pizza with the sauces and toppings that you enjoy. Choose Sauce: Red Sauce, White Sauce, BBQ Sauce, Spicy Red Sauce, Spicy White Sauce		 $12.34
Sad Side
Wing Life Away
Five crispy oven-baked chicken wings tossed in whatever sauce you choose and served with a side of ranch. Choose Sauce: BBQ Sauce, Buffalo Sauce, Garlic Parmesan Sauce, Cowboy BBQ Sauce, Plain Sauce		 $7.07
Saves The Day Sticks
For when you’re two floors down getting high in the back room. Get a full pizza topped with garlic butter, cheese, and Italian seasoning for these cheese sticks for everyone to share. Comes with sides of red sauce and ranch.		 $12.34
New Found Garlic Bread
The perfectly sad side, a hoagie bun with garlic butter and cheese. You were everything I wanted		 $5.05
Sauces on the Side
Red Sauce $0.41
Garlic Butter Sauce $0.41
Ranch Sauce $0.41

… View more

Reviews

Seri Smith
I can’t comment on the food, so I’m trying to be fair with my rating. I was really excited to try this place, but I don’t think it mentions that there is no brick and mortar restaurant anywhere. When I got to the address, I was surprised to find a food delivery hub. I tried to order through Google for pick up, but the order failed. When I tried to order through Postmates, the prices were almost double what the Google menu shows. It would be really nice if there was more consistency and some kind of disclaimer that this is not a restaurant.

… more

E
Honestly, I didn’t have high expectations. Thought it was going to be one of those places I order from once because it’s gimmicky but honestly, good pizza. I enjoyed it along with the emo references.

… more

Andrew Summerford
Their pizza is more than I bargained for when ordering. Everything tastes wonderful. Though the wait is sometimes very long due to low staffing and high demand. Their hours can also be kind of weird so I would pre plan before ordering to make sure everything is in order.

… more

Joseph A
Good pizza if you can get it. Second order never showed up.

… more

Jon S
I’d give this place a zero star if I could, not worth wasting your daily calories on at all.. it’s a sad excuse for a pizza…

… more

Natalie Webb
This emo pizza place is iconic. If you haven’t had Sad Pies, you haven’t lived.

… more

Jonathan
lives up to the name… it was really a sad, bad pie, I am not going to lie….. if your looking for fund raiser pizza this is the place for you !

… more

Sprout Selvaggio
Fantastic pizza with an emo theme, right up my alley

… more

Alli Gurka
THE BEST. The pizza is great every time. Sad pies, happy customers!!!!!!!!!!!!

… more

Jessie Lovano
Creative and tasty pizzas, and great customer service!

… more

… View more

Related:

  1. Pizzano’s Menu – Columbus, OH
  2. Del Baggio Pizzeria Menu – Columbus, OH
  3. Mr. Chicken & Fish Menu – Columbus, OH
  4. Halwani’s Pizza & Stromboli Menu – Columbus, OH

Leave a Comment

Stay connected with the Roost!

Ask us any questions

Get in touch