Pizzas, slices, pasta & heroes served in a laid-back, long-standing pizzeria also offering delivery. Based on 518 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ Delivery
Address:
42 Outwater Ln, Garfield, NJ 07026
Phone: (973) 546-3411
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday | 11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday | 12–10 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–10 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Robert Hernandez
If you’re ever in Garfield, NJ and craving some delicious pizza, Santoni’s Pizza is the place to go! I’ve been a loyal customer for years and they consistently deliver the best pizza around.
… more
Kyle MacDonald
For years I had been hearing my friend tell me about Santoni’s and how their pizza blows away the ‘other guys’ in Garfield. He was not wrong. Plus I don’t think I’ve ever had a better thin crust well done pie in my life. Great little spot that’s doing some promising renovations with a dining area.
… more
Gene Pozniakov
The value for the food at Santoni’s is the best I’ve ever seen. Their penne vodka is a great portion and absolutely delicious, yet somehow it only costs $10, or $13 if you get it with grilled chicken. highly recommend, give their penne vodka a try if you’re in the mood for Italian!
… more
Victoria Mullen
I first had this yesterday for a staff party at work In ridgewood. Actually couldnt stop thinking about how good it was from the ridgewood location all day today. Almost went back to ridgewood today on my day off to get more pizza but noticed this one was closer to me. DELICIOUS, pizza is amazing from both locations. I will happily drive the 30 mins from now on when i want pizza
… more
Victor Maldonado
They’re in the process of renovations for the entire place and it looks like it’s going to look awesome. Food is great. Friendly staff. Definitely one of my go to pizza places in the area.
… more
HONEST REVIEW
Ordered two pizza pies, a grandma with extra sauce and crispy and another being a vegetable pizza. Both tasted great my favorite was def the grandma because of the sauce distinct flavor and chunky plum tomatoes . As for the vegetables pizza it is very limited in choices which I did mention to gentlemen on the front desk (AWSOME guy, very welcoming and kind). I chose olives, green peppers, jalapeño, mushrooms and extra sauce. Pizza topping they were not cheap with the veggies for sure ( $2 per topping). I do recommend them adding maybe more veggie options and cheese to on top of the veggies. Very good crisp on both. I definitely would order again. Grandma for sure. Great guys there. Will come back. Good for family pizza and large gatherings. I attached a pic so you guys can see for yourselves. P.a red flakes are necessary to spice things up! And a little oregano.
… more
Justin P
Penne vodka 10/10
… more
Naomi
LOVE this place. Just moved here and you’d be surprised how many terrible pizza places there are in this town. You can tell a lot about a pizzeria just from a plain slice of pizza and let me tell you as soon as I tried their’s I haven’t gone to any other pizza place.
… more
Sálelease
Best pizza around! I have been a loyal customer since 2007!
… more
Angie Brigitte
I haven been buying pizza from this place for many years. They have the best pizza and costumer service. 🙂
… more
… View more