Classic & creative pizzas, subs & calzones fill the menu at this easygoing Italian chain. Based on 132 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.2 stars. Price $
Address:
424 N Main St, Stillwater, OK 74075
Website: http://www.simplesimonspizza.com/
Social Profile: 
Menu
… View more
Reviews
Aly M
Delivered my pizza mangled and with the cheese falling off, crumpled in the corner of the box.
… more
Luis Sanchez
The food, the workers, and the speed of the place is phenomenal!
… more
Brandon Hammock
I’ve been eating here once or twice for almost 3 years now but not any more. The last 4 times In a row I ate here the pizza was completely soaked in grease. When I told the manager and asked a refund “calmly I might add”, she was extremely sarcastic and talked down to me like I was an idiot and somehow tried to blame me all because she overwhelmed with her orders.
… more
ka4ma touring
We had the BEST first time experience here! The pizza and Calzone were fantastic, and we loved the breadsticks and Alpine Sauce, too! Great sauces, great pizza, great prices, and a great person who helped us and made our order FAST! Thanks for a wonderful meal and see ya again, soon!! 🙂
… more
Harmony Nelson
The two ladies working in there are very unsanitary. One didn’t have a mask on during the pandemic and neither of them wore gloves. One of them was handling, cutting and preparing pizza with NO GLOVES and didn’t wash her hands and I saw her just come back from a delivery. Both of their hair was down and when I mentioned the lack of gloves they seemed nonchalant, like they do it all the time. I wouldn’t risk eating here if you’re concerned for your health.
… more
Lacey Mullinax
I had the best experience on game day here. I felt like I was in a NYC bistro. My family had the Stromboli. It was DELISH!!! The staff was so friendly and courteous. We didn’t wait long for our food. Great experience! We will for sure be eating there again.
… more
Felicia Wellington
Worst pizza ever. Would give 0 stars but had to give one. Should have went with Mazzio’s like I normally do but wanted to try something different. Flavorless, over cooked pizza and mold looking stuff on bottom of the cheese sticks. Family of 4, everybody was disappointed. Total waste of money. Will not be ordering again
… more
Samantha Grider
I’ve been a Simple Simons fan for most of my life! I grew up with one in a quick stop near my house, so I was excited when this location opened! The pizza is always delicious and the calzones can’t be beat. The food is always fresh and fast and the staff is friendly. Simple Simons is a true hidden gem of a pizza place!
… more
Bus_Stop_Said_What
Wanted to try a new pizza place and i must say i wish i had ordered from this place sooner! The food is delicious! It was cooked perfectly! I was blown away by the quality of the food because the price was so good! Definantly found a new place to get my pizza on
… more
Haley Riley
I went to Simple Simon’s a while ago to try their calizone. Their original calizone comes with sausage and pepperoni. However, I just wanted pepperoni so they added more pepperonis for me to replace that sausage. The special of the day was a regular calizone and a large supreme pizza for a discounted price. I’m not a huge fan of supreme pizza, but the manager offered me a different large pizza for another discounted price and even tossed in an order of their Alpine Cheesesticks.
… more
… View more