Started in 1978, this family business is located in the center of Bayport on the corner of Montauk Highway and Bayport Avenue.
The Fish Store provides top-notch fresh fish, live lobsters, dinners to go, dining in our new restaurant, catering and more. Along with great customer service – it is a combination that can’t be beat.
Through our commitment, experience and expertise The Fish Store has established a business relationship with our customers that will last a lifetime!
The Fish Store is a proud member of the Bayport-Blue Point Chamber of Commerce.
Family-run fish specialist serves fresh catch & shellfish in cozy, casual digs with attached market. Based on 477 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.4 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No delivery
Address:
836 Montauk Hwy, Bayport, NY 11705
Phone: (631) 472-3018
Website: http://www.thefishstoreonline.com/
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday |
9 AM–8 PM |
| Wednesday |
9 AM–8 PM |
| Thursday |
9 AM–8 PM |
| Friday |
9 AM–9 PM |
| Saturday |
9 AM–9 PM |
| Sunday |
9 AM–7 PM |
| Monday |
9 AM–7 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Lego “Google user”
This seafood place was a cozy little restaurant. My wife and I celebrated restaurant week and found this spot from a Google search. This restaurant can is visible from a vehicle moving in regular traffic. Lots of parking on the side of the building. Two ways to enter and exit. There is a wheelchair-accessible ramp to enter. There was a short wait of about 10 minutes to get served. The attendant was pleasant and courteous and checked on us regularly. The food was excellent. The menu did not have much low carbs options for eats and alcoholic beverages. The restaurant had a good deal for restaurant week which ends May 1st. One restroom is available for patrons, and an adjacent convenient store under the same name. This restaurant has tables suitable for six people and catered to adults and children. I did not see high chairs in the restaurant or changing tables in the restroom.
… more
Marshall Buck
Wonderful! The BEST SASHIMI & SUSHI and great cooked seafood as well.
… more
Robert Spage
Walked in with my wife and son at 6:45. Half the tables were empty. I’m a very patient person, but my family waited to be acknowledged for 5 minutes as staff walked back and forth. My wife then got the attention of the server, she said she’d be right with us. Fine. Waited 10 more minutes very patiently, as again the staff kept avoiding looking at us. After 15 minutes, we walked out. Not one word from the staff. That’s much longer than most people would wait patiently and quietly. Very unprofessional. Was looking forward to eating there.
… more
Daniel Richards
Just bought a pound of lobster salad here because Claws in Sayville was closed. When I got home and tried it, it tasted unusually sweet and a lot like imitation crab. I still think that it contains imitation crab because it’s the only thing on this earth that I have an allergic reaction to. Called to find out, and the kid on the phone put me on hold to ask the manager. The manager told him that it’s crab meat not imitation crab meat. The sign on the salad tray states, “lobster salad”, not “lobster and crab salad”. What did I pay for? Whatever is sitting in the container is too sweet and tastes awful. I gave it 3 stars instead of 1 because the kid on the phone was kind and seemed concerned. Maybe this store has some noteworthy food but this garbage lobster doesn’t come close to Claws or Brauns.
… more
mike martin
As always the seafood was fresh and amazing. One of the best seafood shops around!!!
… more
Ines P
Nice food and quite an assortment of options, some of which can be fried, sauteed, broiled, etc. My order came to just over $50. I paid $40 in cash and the balance on my credit card, but no receipt for cash was provided. This is not a sound practice. They could be “hiding” cash. Makes one wonder.
… more
Diane Liona
Best fish I ever had! Meal was hot till the last bite! Generous portions…great waitress. E
… more
Johanna Z
Love this place! Coziest dining room on the south shore. Thursday is sushi Thursday, legend Masonori is on hand preparing fresh rolls for diners.
… more
M Towner
Stopped in to pick up lobster bisque for a friend. She said it was great. I picked up some stuffed clams for myself and enjoyed them immensely.
… more
Wendy Arthur
It takes a lot for me to leave a poor review, but this I feel is warranted…. I ordered Chilean Seabass with lemon butter herb sauce. Another choice on the menu was lemon butter dill sauce which I did not want.
… more
… View more
