Tiff’s Love Butta was formulated to enhance food lover’s eating experiences, and to fulfill their most basic needs. Food frees customers to live their lives and pursue happiness. I make a Unique Keto friendly low carb butter that you can put on almost anything. Tiff’s Love Butta was formulated to enhance food lovers eating experiences. My Seafood platters are baked instead of boiled, so flavors are baked in instead of boiled out. My Seafood platters are marinated in Tiff’s love oil, seasoned with Tiff’s Love rub. and Smothered in Tiff’s Love Butta. It is the secret recipe to my food dishes. It makes your food dance. Veggies, Meats, Popcorn, eggs, rice & even warmed up leftovers. Every ounce is Made with Love.
Based on 31 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.9 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Takeout ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
Located in: Circle City Eats Building, 1021 N Pennsylvania St, Indianapolis, IN 46204
Phone: (317) 440-0556
Website: http://tiffslovebutta.com/
Social Profile: 
![]()
Hours
| Sunday |
3–8:45 PM |
| Monday
(Labor Day)
|
4–8 PM
Holiday hours
|
| Tuesday |
Closed |
| Wednesday |
3–8:45 PM |
| Thursday |
5–10:45 PM |
| Friday |
5–10:45 PM |
| Saturday |
5–10:45 PM |
Menu
… View more
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Terri Barbour
Me and my mom went there today! 4/2/2023. I had the pound of snow crab for $35, and my mom had the pound of King Crab dinner for $65. We recently just moved from California and were very pleased to find a seafood restaurant that satisfied our crab leg cravings and most importantly, believed in the wonders of butter. Everything was reasonably priced and the amount of food was perfect to leave you feeling comfortable and not heavy at all. We recommend this place to everybody! And thank you so much Tiff’s!!! We will be coming again!
… more
Karen Smith
First timer!!!
… more
Kevin Bastion
These guys are the real deal. Best seafood I have ever had in my entire life. I ate here every single day that they were open while I was here for a week and I would do it again. I ordered the 4-6ounce lobster tail, pound of shrimp, corn, potatoes and of course their famous Butta. The last meal of my trip they gave me an 8ounce lobster tail instead of 4-6oz that I ordered and wrote “enjoy (:” Are you kidding me? These guys are the absolute best I kid you not.
… more
Krissy Iozzo
The food was fresh and delicious. She went out of the way to accommodate my food allergy and made sure the food was gluten free. We absolutely loved it!
… more
Yanni Dennis
The food was cooked to perfection, every thing was precisely made, but there was no flavor. The customer service was poor the lady who lets the vendors know they have orders was rude twice. I almost did not want to order due to her rudeness. The food was pretty but definitely needs more flavor
… more
Taina
Well where to start?
… more
Joshua Crenchaw
The seafood was great, Tiff’s Love Butta on top was AMAZING. I was scraping the plate and licking my fingers. I would say “I can’t wait to go back….”, but I’m high-key considering ordering again tonight.
… more
Christen Coyle
I had crab legs and lobster!!! It was absolutely the best I’ve ever had!!! Tiff seriously needs to open a restaurant where people can go sit and enjoying her amazing food full of love!!! I am sad that I found this place when I only have a couple days left in Indy!! It was definitely the best food I’ve had in the 13 weeks I’ve been Indy!!!
… more
Erika Moorman
It was good, love the personal feel with the note left on my order. Got a nice portion of king crab for the price! Only reason it wasn’t 5 stars is because I had a lot of shells in my potatoes for some reason and chopped down on a few and it was missing salt and more butter would be nice. Nothing major I’d definitely order again!
… more
Natasha Williams
I couldn’t run here fast enough for a review. Baby you did your THANG! My children and myself enjoyed it to the last drop.
… more
… View more
