Based on 148 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 3.8 stars. Price $
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
3575 Walden Ave, Lancaster, NY 14086
Phone: (716) 302-4105
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Wednesday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Thursday | 11 AM–11 PM |
| Friday | 11 AM–1 AM |
| Saturday | 4 PM–1 AM |
| Sunday | 4–9 PM |
| Monday | 11 AM–11 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Cortney S
Delicious! The sauce is amazing and they have an amazing salad bar and soup of the day selection for lunch. The owner, is the best! Also helps rescue dogs and cats in the community which makes me love the owner and pizza even more!
… more
John Foster
Should be called Perfect Pizza. Delicious! There are a half dozen pizza places within a mile of my home near Main and Transit. Vargo’s is 4.5 miles (9 miles round trip) from me and I choose to go there over all the other because it is so darn good. It’s better the next day than the others and after one bite you can tell they buy their ingredients from a top notch distributer. A+
… more
Nicholas Graham
Ordered a sheet pizza from them a couple times and its been pretty good price and taste. Ordered wings from them a long time ago and they were not up to owners standard so he remade them to make sure it was good before I got them.
… more
hardhouse139
Ordered fingers,wings and pizza. Everything was cooked perfectly and tasted fantastic. I don’t normally leave reviews…but vargo’s deserves it from me. Owner was very friendly and courteous. I will definitely be ordering again. Food was also ready on time to pick up. Nothing bad to say about this pizzeria. Top marks! Thank you Vargo’s. Look forward to ordering again very soon!
… more
Charles Williams
Simple pie, half pep, half cheese. Vargos 110%, owner is great. Been missing this place. Real ingredients best pizza spot in Buffalo perhaps…
… more
Michael Caputo
Best chicken wings I’ve had in a while. Not just franks red hot!! Chicken wings are evolving get them here first! Thanks for the double order guys!
… more
Traci Roll
Grew up having Vargos as a kid . Just as good as when the owners father ran the place back in the day (where Picasso’s is now)
… more
Taylor Franzek
The owner was having issues with the delivery service the restaurant uses so I offered to come and pick up our food. He was so appreciative and before I even tried the food I knew I would come back and give him business just for his kindness and sincerity. Then we got home with the food and it did not disappoint. One of the best chicken finger pizzas I’ve ever had! He even made us new fries because they sat out for too long before I arrived and made sure the pizza was still hot. Places are struggling right now and your hard work has not gone unnoticed. We’ll see you soon, Thank you!
… more
mizener zachary
Called at 10:11pm was told it was going to be delivered within an HR. A large pizza extra cheese sausage pepperoni and bacon, one dozen mild wings at the tune of 68$ its is now 11:42 no delivery yet and tipped driver 5 bucks for delivery on my card worked 16 hrs today just wanted some dinner
… more
Thomas H
Order delivery from their resturant website. At 7:26pm, original delivery time estimated at 8:26 to 8:41pm. Price for 3 cold turkey subs and delivery >$50. Then email received with updated time: 8:48 to 9:03pm. I called the resturant at 8:49pm asking for an update, they told me she would be out with my order when she got back. Called back for another update at 9:07pm, gentleman who answered was short and said “soon as you hang up I’ll hand her the subs and she’ll be able to be on her way” received subs at 9:15pm. The subs are so so small. I mean they are tiny. I highly recommend you avoid this establishment
… more
… View more