Goodfellas pizza Italian restaurant is a family run business that takes great pride in providing delicious Italian American food, fine wines beers and cordials and yes delicious authentic Italian desserts at reasonable prices. Founded in 2016 GOODFELLAS has been working become an active part of our community contributing to our local schools in Port Jervis in Delaware Valley. Providing donations of food and gift certificates to local charitable organizations. We aim to provide a quiet friendly atmosphere where family and friends can gather Enjoying delicious food drinks and great customer service. We look forward to serving you
Based on 459 reviews, the restaurant has received a rating of 4.1 stars. Price $$
✔️ Dine-in ✔️ Curbside pickup ✔️ No-contact delivery
Address:
111 Hulst Dr, Matamoras, PA 18336
Phone: (570) 491-8191
Website:
Social Profile: 
Hours
| Tuesday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Wednesday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Thursday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Friday |
11 AM–10 PM |
| Saturday |
11 AM–10 PM |
| Sunday |
11 AM–9 PM |
| Monday |
11 AM–9 PM |
Menu
… View more
Menu Photos
Photo Gallery
Reviews
Ewa Skading-Bednarska
This restaurant is a mistake. If I could, I wouldn’t give any stars. We ordered pizzas. Some of the order came immediately and some after 45 minutes. The pizzas were so-so. But I have never encountered such service in any restaurant before. “An older woman with probably yellow hair was serving us. From the very moment we entered, she was very unpleasant and rude. I congratulate the owner on the choice of staff. She should leave her rude behavior at home. We didn’t leave there because the kids ate their pizzas, although we should. But we will never go there again, even though we live in the area. I tell my friends to avoid this place. After eating pizza chicken alfredo, we spent the whole Saturday afternoon in the toilets. Nightmare. You run a very bad restaurant with a very bad waitress (old woman). How dare you write that my opinion is fictitious???. You have no idea how to run a restaurant!! You take care of this unpleasant person and don’t waste your time on such answers. They only prove your lack of respect for the client and lack of professionalism. I hope that there will be less and less such restaurants in our area. And you don’t embarrass yourself anymore.
… more
evelia rodriguez
Food was worth the wait! The Buffalo wings were PERFECT! Salad was great came with good amounts of chicken. Definitely recommend!
… more
McAteer & Will Estates with Keller Williams
Goodfellas Pizza Italian Restaurant in Matamoras, PA, delivers a delicious experience reminiscent of its cinematic namesake. With an extensive menu featuring a variety of mouthwatering Italian dishes and, of course, pizzas, the restaurant offers a genuine taste of Italy. Great place for a last minute dinner if you prefer to not cook.
… more
Angelica Ornelas-Skaggs
We absolutely love this place, and the food is always spot on. Best Pizza we’ve had since being up here! Customer service is the best!
… more
Brandon Ledbetter
Amazing food, and so many choices! Great prices.
… more
Barbara Jacques (BEJ)
So good! The personal pizzas will easily feed 2 and we’re delish. Fresh veggies added a perfect crunch to the veggie pizza. Service was quick and friendly. Restrooms were clean. Definitely found our new lunch spot when we trek from New England to Southern PA!
… more
Dustin Stevens
Traveling through we stopped here for lunch quick. We ordered a medium pizza thinking it would feed 3 of us with no leftovers but when it came out it was huge! Pizza was good with no complaints. Would stop again if in the area.
… more
Antonios Giannakas
The place has great atmosphere. Some great people work there. The best ones are early in the day. They have humor too. I told them they are lucky I am not opening a pizza place next to them, they got the joke which is a major +. Their pizza crust is as good as it gets
… more
Jeremy Gossett
Carl and Karen will treat you like family! I received the absolute best hospitality, I really hope I’m able to stop in again! I travel all over, but this has been my favorite pizza place by far to stop at!
… more
Sylwia Popkin
Horrible service..our waitress was rude and practically yelled at me for trying to sit in a virtually empty restaurant. She proceeded to be completely confused by my order of a pizza from the menu and wrote down that I wanted a pasta dish. After about a 40 minute wait she brought the pie and tried to pull the slices apart with her bare hands (after having just wiped down dirty tables) disgusting! Get better wait staff please!
… more
… View more
